BARRON'S BOOK NOTES (tm) on CD-ROM Windows (tm) Ver. 2.0
Scarlet Letter Nathaniel Hawthorne
---------------------------------------------------------
1850
NATHANIEL HAWTHORNE'S
THE SCARLET LETTER
by Sara Sheldon
SERIES EDITOR
Michael Spring, Editor
Literary Cavalcade, Scholastic Inc.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We would like to acknowledge the many painstaking hours of work
Holly Hughes and Thomas F. Hirsch have devoted to making the
Book Notes series a success.
(C) Copyright 1984 by Barron's Educational Series, Inc.
Electronically Enhanced Text (C) Copyright 1993, World Library, Inc.
CONTENTS
SECTION.......................... SEARCH ON
THE AUTHOR AND HIS TIMES................. HSCAAUTH
THE NOVEL
The Plot................................. HSCAPLOT
The Characters........................... HSCACHAR
Other Elements
Setting............................. HSCASETT
Themes.............................. HSCATHEM
Symbolism........................... HSCASYMB
Structure........................... HSCASTRU
THE STORY................................ HSCASTOR
A STEP BEYOND
Tests and Answers........................ HSCATEST
Term Paper Ideas......................... HSCATERM
Glossary................................. HSCAGLOS
The Critics.............................. HSCACRIT
Advisory Board........................... HSCAADVB
Bibliography............................. HSCABIBL
AUTHOR_AND_HIS_TIMES
THE AUTHOR AND HIS TIMES (HSCAAUTH)
-
It was a brash, bustling, energetic country in which Hawthorne
grew up and carved out his writing career. The covered wagons were
rolling West, with signs that bravely declared "California or bust!"
The first passenger railroad opened, and the trains went huffing and
puffing along at the (then) incredible speed of 20 miles an hour.
Jackson was elected president, throwing the conservative statesmen out
of office and ushering in the age of democracy and the common man.
It was an age between wars, when America, having beaten England
for the second time- in the War of 1812- was flexing its adolescent
muscles. Hope was in the air, and also a feeling of impatience with
the imported, second-hand, European way of doing things. "Down with
the past" might have been the slogan of the time. Americans sensed a
fresh, creative task at hand in the building of a new country. It
was a task that called for strong backs, clear eyes, and open minds.
There were experiments in living going on to match the experiments
in politics and technology. Starry-eyed intellectuals gathered outside
Boston to thrive on a vegetarian diet at Alcott's Fruitlands.
Thoreau conducted his own private experiments in a life close to
nature at Walden Pond. Horace Mann planned to change the world by
changing education.
Where was Hawthorne while all this excitement was going on? In his
bedroom in Salem, reading a book. You get the distinct feeling about
this man that, so far as the great adventures of his time were
concerned, he simply wasn't paying attention. Hawthorne was gazing
intelligently off in another direction. Most of his generation
looked expectantly toward the future. Hawthorne kept his eyes on the
past.
He was an introvert, almost a recluse, this native son of Salem,
Massachusetts. After graduating from Bowdoin College, he spent close
to twelve years at home in his room, reading and learning his writer's
craft. For subject matter, he turned not to life but to books and to
his own family history. When he was a boy, his Puritan ancestors had
haunted his imagination. And now, he read voraciously about early
New England history, fleshing out his childhood dreams.
Perhaps Hawthorne read so much about the Puritans that their
concerns became his. More likely, his reading struck a chord in him
that was already familiar. Hawthorne thought about sin. He thought
about guilt. He thought about the dark side of the soul. He pondered
questions that few other men of his time thought or cared about-
questions like: What happens to people who nurse a secret sin
throughout their lives? Or, is it true that the evil taint of a
crime lingers forever on the soul?
Hawthorne had a wide, unconventional streak in his soul, and he
didn't like it. Some part of him was always at war with the recluse
and pessimist in himself.
Hawthorne even briefly flirted with Utopianism. He joined Brook
Farm, a community near Boston, in the hopes that a life in the open
air, in communion with other writers, would be congenial to him. But
milking cows and raking manure proved too much for Hawthorne. He
left after a year to resume a private writing career.
Hawthorne made other attempts to put himself in touch with the
currents of his time. At the age of 35, he sought- of all things- a
political appointment. Hawthorne went to work in the Salem Custom
House, where his nose was really rubbed in the grimy details of trade.
There was a good reason for that particular choice. Hawthorne had
met his future wife, Sophia Peabody, and he needed money to marry
on. He was never a best-selling author, and a lack of funds was a
problem he would wrestle with all his life.
The question of money would rear its ugly head again in 1846 when
Hawthorne, now a husband and a father, returned to the Salem Custom
House as Surveyor. He spent three mildly discontented years there,
to be thrown out in 1849 when a Whig victory ended the Democrats'
reign. (Hawthorne was a member of the Democratic party.)
Hawthorne was bitter at such high-handed treatment. But his
dismissal from the Custom House proved a blessing in disguise. He
was free to write again. Indeed, he had to write in order to keep a
roof over his head. He set immediately to work and produced The
Scarlet Letter, published in 1850.
Perhaps the novel served as a kind of creative trigger, for the
famous works now followed quickly, one on the heels of another: The
House of the Seven Gables in 1851, and The Blithedale Romance in 1852.
We can talk about the later events of Hawthorne's life: the birth of
more children, a consulship to England, the publication of The
Marble Faun in 1860. And yet, if we do, we will get no closer to the
man. Hawthorne lived a decent, middle-class, intellectual sort of
life. He wrote, he served his country in minor capacities, he had
children, he worked to support them. And yet, there was something he
held back, a part of himself he showed only to the four walls of his
room.
Nathaniel Hawthorne was a man, for instance, who married a
genteel, delicate woman, a woman to whom love meant the sweet sound of
violins. But the creator of Hester Prynne knew a different side of
things; knew just as surely as he lived that there were dark, erotic
temptresses out there with eyes a man could drown in.
PLOT
THE PLOT (HSCAPLOT)
The year is 1642. The place is Boston, a small Puritan settlement.
Before the town jail, a group of somber people wait with stern
expressions on their faces. They are expecting Hester Prynne, a
woman convicted of adultery and condemned to stand on the village
scaffold for three hours of public shame.
Hester appears, carrying an infant in her arms, and wearing a
scarlet letter A (for Adulteress) as a badge of her disgrace. A
careful look at Hester's face, however, shows she is not contrite,
as the crowd expects, but rather quietly defiant. Three hours on the
scaffold do little to change her attitude. When pressed by the
magistrates to repent of her crime and name her lover to the
authorities, Hester answers with a silence that echoes through the
market-place. She scorns her judges. To one man alone does she show
any sign of fear.
That man is Hester's husband who has just arrived in town, having
sent Hester ahead from Europe two years before. Taking quick stock
of the situation, he disguises his identity and assumes a new one,
that of Roger Chillingworth, physician. Before Hester's ordeal is
over, Chillingworth has made his plans. He will stay in Boston and
search out his unnamed rival.
That night, Chillingworth visits Hester in prison to secure her
promise of secrecy. The world must not know him as her husband. Hester
agrees to Chillingworth's demands, partly out of exhaustion, partly
out of fear that her husband will indeed find and expose her lover. It
is a promise she will live to regret.
The years go by. Hester, released from prison, moves with her
daughter Pearl to a small cottage on the outskirts of town. There
she earns a meager living as a seamstress. Though Hester's conduct
is now quiet and modest, her life is made hell on earth by the
unforgiving citizens of Boston who shun her, or insult her, as the
woman of the scarlet letter.
There is even an attempt, led by the Governor himself, to take
Hester's child from her. But the attempt fails when Hester goes to the
Governor's mansion to fight in person for Pearl. There she enlists the
aid of Arthur Dimmesdale, the colony's revered young minister, who
argues convincingly on Hester's behalf. In the meantime, Chillingworth
has made quite a name for himself as a doctor. He has approached
Dimmesdale, who is not well, with an offer of his services. Dimmesdale
is gently pressured into accepting medical treatment. And
Chillingworth takes the opportunity to cement first a professional
relationship and then an intimate friendship with the minister.
What is Chillingworth up to? He has his suspicions that Dimmesdale
is the man he is looking for, the man who should have stood by
Hester's side on the scaffold. Chillingworth now watches, listens,
tests, and probes, until he finds what he is looking for: an A on
Dimmesdale's chest (we might call it a psychosomatic sign) just like
the letter worn by Hester Prynne.
Dimmesdale is the guilty man; he is also a guilt-ridden one. The
secret the minister carries within him is burning to get out. He
starts to confess in his sermons, but cowardice holds him back. He
reels to the scaffold to stand vigil where Hester has stood and goes
to the telltale spot, unseen, in the dead of night.
Dimmesdale's torment is increased by Chillingworth, who takes his
revenge by playing on the minister's guilt. It is Hester who calls a
halt to the physician's ugly game. She has seen how suffering has
wasted Dimmesdale away. She accuses herself of leaving him-
unknowing and unaware- a victim in her estranged husband's hands.
Hester meets Dimmesdale in the forest to tell him the truth about
Chillingworth. The meeting reawakens passionate feelings in them both.
Hester and Dimmesdale plan to escape. They will go to England, where
Chillingworth cannot follow, and there they will build a new and
better life.
Between the meeting in the forest and the day planned for escape,
however, something snaps in Dimmesdale. The minister has a change of
heart. He is a dying man, and he knows it. He holds himself together
long enough to give the most triumphant sermon of his life. Then he
mounts the scaffold (this time in daylight) to confess his sin and
to die in Hester's arms.
The story has a postscript. Chillingworth dies with his victim and
leaves his money to- of all people- Pearl. Hester and her daughter
leave New England for Europe, where Pearl marries an aristocrat.
Hester, now alone, returns to Boston where she resumes, of her own
accord, the scarlet letter. Years later, when she dies, she is
buried in a grave next to the minister's, where one tombstone, with an
engraved letter A, serves for them both.
CHARACTERS
THE CHARACTERS (HSCACHAR)
HESTER PRYNNE
Hester Prynne is one of the most enigmatic characters in all
literature. As the wearer of the scarlet letter, she may be expected
to possess some definitive insight available to no one else. Yet her
final word on the subject is "I know not. I know not."
Is Hester a glorious heroine, standing up to an unduly repressive
society in the name of love and freedom? Or is she a sinner who has
broken a basic and sacred law? And if she is a sinner, does sin lead
her in the direction of evil or of good?
Let's look at Hester from a number of different viewpoints:
1. Hester is a magnificent woman fighting for her natural rights
to love and freedom. To know what Hawthorne means by his heroine,
you have only to look at her. With her flashing eyes, her rich
complexion, and her abundant hair, she stands for what a real woman
should be beside a crowd of tight-mouthed Puritans.
It is true that during the years of her punishment, Hester tries
to subdue her spirit and sensuality, hiding it all (with that
wonderful hair of hers) beneath a sad cap. But she can't do it. One
breath of fresh air, one ray of sunlight, one moment alone with her
lover in the forest, and she is herself again, reaching passionately
for a life of freedom and fulfillment.
2. Hester Prynne, if not the out-and-out criminal the Puritans
believe her to be, is still a woman who has deeply sinned. She is,
after all, guilty of adultery- no small matter, even today.
As Hester herself admits, she has irreparably wronged her husband.
And so she bears some responsibility for the corruption of
Chillingworth's soul.
She has also shattered Dimmesdale's peace. She has lured the
minister- admittedly, with his full cooperation- from the straight and
narrow path of orthodoxy, where it was surely in his interest to stay.
3. Hester is, indeed, a sinner. But her sin is a cause not of evil
but of good. Suffering disciplines Hester, so that she grows strong.
Sorrow awakens her sympathies, so that she becomes a nurse.
In fact, the best deeds of Hester's life come about through her fall
from grace. Her charity to the poor, her comfort to the
broken-hearted, her unquestioned presence in times of trouble are
the direct result of her search for repentance. If Hester had not
sinned, she would never have discovered the true depths of
tenderness within herself.
4. Hester is neither a heroine nor a sinner, but something in
between. She is a flesh-and-blood woman in tragic circumstances,
trapped in a loveless marriage and in love with another man. Whichever
way she moves, there is bound to be a sacrifice of some vital part
of herself, either her honor or her deepest need.
ARTHUR DIMMESDALE
Dimmesdale is a coward and a hypocrite. Worse, he is a
self-confessed coward and hypocrite. He knows what he has to do to
still the voice of his conscience and make his peace with God. He
simply cannot bring himself to do it.
Dimmesdale is somewhat pale and weak from the first moment we see
him. And he grows paler and weaker by the minute, as he lives ridden
with guilt, a guiltmonger by his side. By the time the minister
comes to the forest, he barely has the strength to throw himself
down on the leaves in the hope that he can lie there forever. He lacks
the will even to wish to live or die.
When we read such a description, we cannot help wondering what
Hester ever saw in the man.
Yet there is a presence in the minister that demands a live audience
and knows how to sway one. We see it in his eyes- large, brown, and
melancholy- which seem to search out men's souls. We hear it in his
voice- sweet, deep, broken- a finely tuned instrument for touching
women's hearts.
Were Dimmesdale just a little stronger, a little more energetic,
we would say he has charisma. And probably, in his own time and place,
he did. Ministers were the Puritan culture's heroes. Hester would have
met Dimmesdale first as the revered idol of the community, the
object of worshipping glances from every girl in sight.
We sense in Dimmesdale this split between his private and his public
...
Januszek66