Crucible Arthur Miller
---------------------------------------------------------
1953
ARTHUR MILLER'S
THE CRUCIBLE
by William Bly
Assistant Professor of Drama, New York University
SERIES COORDINATOR
Michael Spring, Editor,
Literary Cavalcade, Scholastic Inc.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We would like to acknowledge the many painstaking hours of work
Holly Hughes and Thomas F. Hirsch have devoted to making the Book
Notes series a success.
(C) Copyright 1984 by Barron's Educational Series, Inc.
Electronically Enhanced Text (C) Copyright 1993, World Library, Inc.
CONTENTS
SECTION.......................... SEARCH ON
THE AUTHOR AND HIS TIMES..................... MCRUAUTH
THE PLAY
The Plot..................................... MCRUPLOT
The Characters............................... MCRUCHAR
Other Elements
Setting................................. MCRUSETT
Themes.................................. MCRUTHEM
Style................................... MCRUSTYL
Point of View........................... MCRUVIEW
Form and Structure...................... MCRUFORM
Some Notes on Reading the Play.......... MCRUNOTE
THE STORY.................................... MCRUSTOR
A STEP BEYOND
Tests and Answers............................ MCRUTEST
Term Paper Ideas............................. MCRUTERM
The Critics.................................. MCRUCRIT
Advisory Board............................... MCRUADVB
Bibliography................................. MCRUBIBL
AUTHOR_AND_HIS_TIMES
THE AUTHOR AND HIS TIMES (MCRUAUTH)
-
In Salem, Massachusetts, a dozen teen-age girls and a black slave
woman are caught dancing in the woods around a bubbling cauldron.
Today, you wouldn't even use the word "caught." You might think
these girls were strange, but you'd hardly call the cops on them.
But it's 1692, and Salem isn't just an ordinary small town; it's a
religious community of the strictest kind. The people and their laws
are as harsh as the Massachusetts winter. When two of the girls pass
out from fright and can't be revived, the others find themselves in
serious trouble. Women who dance with the Devil are witches; and
witches, when they are caught, are hanged. To get themselves out of
their predicament, the girls try to spread the blame around. But the
blame-spreading gets out of hand, and before long the whole town is in
a panic, everyone accusing everyone else of witchcraft. Nineteen
people will be hanged before the madness is stopped.
Well, you say, people were superstitious then. Nothing like that
could happen today. Maybe so, but in the early 1950s, at the time
The Crucible was written, a similar kind of hunt was taking place, not
for witches, but for Communists. Today it bears the
harmless-sounding name of the McCarthy Hearings on Un-American
Activities, but for the people who got caught up in it- some of them
our parents and grandparents- this "witch-hunt" was anything but
harmless. in fact, to the playwright Arthur Miller, the McCarthy
Hearings bore an alarming resemblance to the trials in Salem in
1692. The Crucible was his way of trying to keep history from
repeating itself.
One of the most popular TV shows in 1953 was "I Led Three Lives." It
always began the same way: A man's face appears on the screen. His
expression is taut with anxiety. The narrator says something like,
"This is the fantastically true story of Herbert A. Philbrick, who for
nine frightening years did lead three lives- average citizen, member
of the Communist Party, and counterspy for the FBI. For obvious
reasons, the names, dates and places have been changed, but the
story is based on fact." The show was scary and exciting, but it
always left you worried, because Philbrick's job never seemed to be
done. Communist spies were everywhere, and one man could do only so
much against so many.
There was a lot of talk in those days about the "Red Menace." Red is
the color of the Russian flag, and all Russians are Communists. So
to say "Better dead than red" meant that you'd kill yourself before
you let the Communists take over. The slogan was repeated over and
over throughout America. My father said it; my teachers said it; I'm
sure I said it myself, even though I was just five years old at the
time.
And in fact there were good reasons to be worried about the
Russians. They had the atomic bomb, as we did. But a lot of people
said they got the bomb by using spies, and that really made us
worry. It was charged that secret agents, working under cover, had
stolen our secrets and given them to the Enemy. Even worse, these
spies supposedly were hardly ever Russians themselves, but often
American citizens, as normal as you or me, the kind of people you
see every day on the street and hardly even notice. Blacks are
identifiable by their skin color, foreigners speak with an unusual
accent. But a Communist could be anybody. It sort of makes a Communist
sound like the bogey-man, doesn't it? Well, to many people in 1953,
a Communist was just as scary as the bogey-man, and a lot more real.
Soon after it was discovered that the Russians had the bomb, the
U.S. Congress started investigations into so-called Un-American
Activities, and one of the men they put in charge was Joseph R.
McCarthy, a senator from Wisconsin. McCarthy claimed America was in
great danger from a Communist conspiracy to take over the world.
And, as if he were a surgeon hacking away tumors in a body riddled
with cancer, he tried to root out every trace of Communism he could
find. It soon became clear that very few people were completely free
of any connection with Communism. To find out why, we have to go back
in time a little bit.
Arthur Miller had just turned 14 when His family's savings were
wiped out by the stock market crash of October, 1929. Almost literally
overnight, the lives of many of his friends changed from reasonable
comfort to poverty. Over the next 12 years- the time of the Great
Depression, as it is called- Arthur Miller came to know and work
with people who had joined the Communist Party. These people weren't
spies, they simply were desperate, and they saw Communism as a way out
of a desperate situation. And although Communism worried a few
people in the 1930s, most were too busy with their own problems to
give it much thought. Besides, Soviet Russia was not yet an enemy of
the United States. In fact, Russian and American soldiers later fought
side by side against the Germans at the end of World War II. It wasn't
until after the war, when- as so often happens- the victor's turned
against each other, that Communism began to be considered a very
serious threat.
By the late 1940s when the Congressional hearings first began, there
were quite a few people who had flirted with Communism at some time or
other, although most had renounced it long before. But even if you had
no Communism in your own past, you could easily be in the same
position as Arthur Miller- you knew someone who did. That was more
than enough to get you in trouble with Senator McCarthy and similar
investigators.
Imagine what it was like being called in to testify. McCarthy or his
aides might say, "Are you now, or have you ever been, a member of
the Communist Party?" No. "Do you know anyone who is or was a
Communist?" No. McCarthy holds up some cards. "We have the names of
people who have already confessed. Your name came up in connection
with their testimony. Why do you suppose that is?" You say you don't
know, but you can tell that no one believes you. Maybe you're not so
innocent after all, you think. Maybe you've been sucked into the
conspiracy without realizing it. Have you signed anything, donated any
money, said anything to anybody that might sound suspicious?
Once you start thinking like this, it's almost impossible to stop.
You begin to feel guilty either way: even if you don't have any
Communist connections, you've done nothing to stop the spread of
this evil; You may have even helped the enemy by being stupid or
naive. You did it, it's your fault, their questions seem to say. And
they won't let you go until you make up for it in some way. So you
tell them about your friend who's never home on Tuesday nights, or
your mother's uncle who used to quote Communist slogans all the
time, or anyone you know who's been acting a little odd the last few
weeks. You name names, and they let you go.
And afterward no one wants anything to do with you. You were
called in to testify, there had to be a reason. You must be a
Communist, or at least have been working for them. You lose your
friends, your job, sometimes even your family. You become an
outcast. Your life is ruined.
This was the fate of many innocent people. Those who were spared
either joined in the witch-hunt or kept silent for fear the same thing
would happen to them. A lot of the victim never recovered, even long
after the rest of the country lost interest and Joe McCarthy had
been discredited. By 1957 it was pretty much over, and America could
look back with a sad smile, wondering how anyone could have been so
foolish.
But in 1953 it was no joke. Arthur Miller already knew about the
Salem witch trials from his college days at the University of Michigan
(1934-38). In The Theater Essays of Arthur Miller he describes how The
Crucible took shape in his mind:"... when the McCarthy era came
along," he says, "I remembered these stories and I used to tell them
to people when it [the investigation] started. I used to say, you
know, McCarthy is actually saying certain lines that I recall the
witch-hunters saying in Salem. So I started to go back, not with the
idea of writing a play, but to refresh my own mind because it was
getting eerie".
One day, while he was reading some documents in the Salem museum,
some tourists came in and wanted to see the pins. There was no need to
ask, "What pins?" During the trials in 1692, the so-called witches
often "sent out their spirits" to stick pins into the flesh of the
girls who were accusing them. Now, as Arthur Miller watched, "the
tourists pass the books, the exhibits, and no hint of danger reaches
them from the quaint relics. I have a desire to tell them the
significance of those relics. It is the desire to write".
The significance of those relics was, in part, that the same thing
that happened in 1692 was happening all over again. "It was not only
the rise of 'McCarthyism' that moved me," he writes, "but something
which seemed much more weird and mysterious. It was the fact that a
political, objective, knowledgeable campaign from the far Right
[Communists were said to be on the far left] was capable of creating
not only a terror, but a new subjective reality... and that such
manifestly ridiculous men [as Senator Joe McCarthy] should be
capable of paralyzing thought itself.... it was as though the whole
country had been born anew, without a memory.... Astounded, I
watched men pass me by without a nod whom I had known rather well
for years...." And so Arthur Miller began to write The Crucible.
A few years before, Arthur Miller had become famous. His second
play, Death of a Salesman, had won the 1949 Pulitzer Prize and a
host of other awards. By the time he was 37, in 1952, he was a
respected writer of established reputation, and people were looking
forward to his next play. What he had to say was bound to be
important.
There's a saying that a prophet is honored everywhere except in
his own country. This could certainly be said of the author of The
Crucible when it first opened on Broadway on January 22, 1953. No
one missed the parallels between 1692 Salem and 1953 America. "But,"
many said, "witches never did exist, then or now. Communists are
real." Some critics complained that the play was too cold and
intellectual. Others said it wasn't a play at all, but some kind of
outburst, a political speech. Most people found a way of saying that
it wasn't worth bothering with. The play ran for a few months, playing
to almost empty houses. Then it closed. But the witch-hunt went on.
Arthur Miller had drawn a lot of attention to himself, and he soon
got into trouble. In 1954 he was denied a passport to see a production
of The Crucible in Belgium. In 1955 the New York City Youth Board
began an investigation into his political beliefs. In 1956 he was
called on to testify before the House Committee on Un-American
Activities. He refused to name names. He was cited for contempt of
Congress. He was finally exonerated by the courts, but not until 1958.
By then, more and more people were refusing to testify against others,
and the witch-hunt was running out of steam. The hearings had gone
on for ten years, and the country's attention span was near its end.
In all that time, no real Communist conspiracy was ever uncovered.
Just as no real witches were ever found in Salem.
Another important thing happened in 1958: The Crucible was put on
again, this time in a small Off-Broadway theater. "The same critics
reviewed it again," Arthur Miller remembers, and "this time they
were fairly swept away, the drama was as real to them [now, in 1958]
as it had been cold and undramatic before [in 1953]. Reasons were
given for the new impression; the main one was that the script had
been improved." Miller hadn't changed a word in the script. He began
to think that the real reason had more to do with the audience than
the play: "...when McCarthyism was around, the... audience [was] quite
simply in fear of the theme of the play, which was witch-hunting. In
[1958] they were not afraid of it, and they began to look at the play"
(Theater Essays, p. 245).
Most of the time when an author writes a play about current
events, the play is forgotten as soon as the events are over. But
The Crucible has come to be produced more often than even Death of a
Salesman, which was long considered to be Arthur Miller's most
important play. Let's see if we can figure out why.
If you're watching a really scary film, say, The Exorcist, you can
always reassure yourself by saying, "It's only a movie." But you can't
do that with The Crucible. The witch-hunt really happened. You can
go to Salem today and still find the house where Rebecca Nurse
lived, and see the door through which she was carried to her trial
because she was too old and sick to walk. You can stand on the rock
where the gallows was built, and look out over Salem Bay, the same bay
19 "witches" must have looked at just before they were hanged. You can
go to the courthouse and they'll show you the pins.
Nowadays we don't believe in witches or the Devil, at least we say
we don't. But we're still fascinated by the idea of supernatural
forces and beings. And, for most of us, the scarier the better. The
popularity of horror movies comes from this fascination. The
Crucible also tells a strange and scary story. But in this play it's
not witches or demons that scare us- it's people. Arthur Miller's
characters are ordinary folk. The terror that sweeps over them like
a wave is real; the people who were hanged really died. In The
Crucible there are no real witches; so what, then, "possessed" these
people?
If you've ever built a wood fire, you know it doesn't start
itself. And the biggest logs won't burn right away; you have to
begin with smaller sticks, the kindling. But there can be no fire at
all without a spark to set the kindling burning.
We can think of the Salem witchcraft as a kind of fire which, once
started, could not be quenched until it had burned itself out.
By this analogy, the big logs would be the belief in witchcraft
itself. This belief was an old one. In the ancient world, sorcery
was everywhere- in Egypt and Babylon, even among the clear-thinking
Greeks and the otherwise sensible Romans. Only the Jews, among all
these ancient peoples, had laws forbidding the practice of witchcraft.
It is first mentioned in the Old Testament (Exodus 22:18), where it
says, "Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live." It was on the authority
of this one sentence in the Bible that the 19 witches were hanged in
Salem in 1692.
But until the end of the Middle Ages, no one had made a "scientific"
study of the spirit world, and ideas about witches varied wildly
from place to place and century to century. Then in 1486 two Christian
monks brought out a book called the Malleus Maleficarum (The Hammer of
Witches), the first book of demonology. Others soon followed (King
James I of England even wrote one himself), and by the time Reverend
Hale walked into Salem in 1692 with an armload of such books, the
study of witchcraft was considered an exact science. When he says of
his books, "Here is all the invisible world, caught, defined, and
calculated," he is being sincere. He has studied these books for years
and he honestly believes himself to be an expert. So does everyone
else. There is no reason to doubt him or his ability to deal with an
enemy he knows so much about. Without this solid and specific belief
...
Januszek66