Identyfikacja genetyczna ofiary postrzału po czterech latach od zgonu.pdf

ARCH. MED. SĄD. KRYM., 2009, LIX, 248-251 PRACE KAZUISTYCZNE

Anna Niemcunowicz-Janica, Witold Pepiński, Jacek Robert Janica 1 ,

Małgorzata Skawrońska

Genetic identification of a gunshot victim four years posthumously

Identyfikacja genetyczna ofiary postrzału

po czterech latach od zgonu

Department of Forensic Medicine, Medical University of białystok, Poland

Head: prof. J. Janica

1 Department of Radiology, Medical University of białystok, Poland

Head: dr U. łebkowska

Praca przedstawia wyniki genetycznych badań iden-

tyfikacyjnych ofiary postrzału, której ciało zostało

wydobyte po 4 latach od zgonu z dołu ziemnego

wypełnionego wapnem. badanie sekcyjne wyka-

zało obecność zaawansowanych zmian gnilnych

oraz częściowo przemiany tłuszczowo-woskowej.

Ze zmian urazowych stwierdzono obecność dwóch

ran postrzałowych głowy i klatki piersiowej, które

doprowadziły do zgonu. Zarówno stan zwłok, jak

i brak bliższych danych medycznych uniemożliwiały

ustalenie tożsamości zwłok. Zabezpieczony do ba-

dań materiał, w postaci fragmentów tkanek miękkich,

pozwolił na pełną identyfikację w oparciu o analizę

genetyczną.

material for genetic typing, the femur, brain, lung,

kidney and spleen samples were collected. DNA

templates were extracted by a modified organic

procedure and genotyped with the use of AmpFlSTR

Identifiler Amplification Kit and PowerPlex Y System

in an AbI 310 Genetic Analyzer (Applied biosystems).

All the soft tissue samples yielded sufficient quantity

and quality of DNA to perform genetic profiling.

Słowa kluczowe: obrażenia postrzałowe,

rozkład, identyfikacja osobnicza, DNA, Amp-

FlSTR Identifiler, PowerPlex Y

Key words: Gunshot wounds, decomposi-

tion, personal identification, DNA typing,

AmpFlSTR Identifiler, PowerPlex Y

The paper presents a personal identification case of

an unrecognized corpse, presumably belonging to

a male missing for four years. The cadaver was buried

in a ground ditch and covered with slaked lime and

soil. During the investigation the burial place was

indicated. The corpse was exhumed and afterwards

transferred to the Department of Forensic Medicine,

Medical University of białystok. External examination

and autopsy findings demonstrated adipocere

formation and putrefaction, as well as two gunshot

wounds in the thorax and the head assumed to be

the cause of death. Personal identification procedure

included skeletal and dental examination. As a source

INTRODUCTION

Genetic profiling has been integrated with

personal identification of unrecognized corpses

and remains an element of the procedure ow-

ing to its discrimination power and potential

typeability of decomposed biological material

[1]. In consecutive stages of postmortem de-

composition, human hard tissues, e.g. bones,

and teeth have been the most suitable material

for genetic identification [2, 3, 4, 5]; however,

Nr 3 249

IDENTYFIKACJA GENETYCZNA OFIARY POSTRZAłU

their processing and DNA extraction is relatively

costly and time-consuming. Taking into consid-

eration papers reporting possible genotyping

of decomposed human tissues [6, 7, 8, 9], the

authors collected several soft tissue samples

during the autopsy to verify their usefulness as

a source of genetic profile.

D21S11, D7S820, CSF1PO, D3S1358, TH01,

D13S317, D16S539, D2S1338, D19S433, vWA,

TPOX, D18S51, D5S818, FGA, AMG included

in the AmpFlSTR Identifiler PCR Amplification

Kit (Applied biosystems) and Y-chromosomal

systems: DYS19, DYS385, DYS389I/II, DYS390,

DYS391, DYS392, DYS393, DYS437, DYS438,

DYS439 included in the PowerPlex Y System

(Promega) were amplified following the manu-

facturers’ instructions with the exception, that

the all reaction reagents were reduced propor-

tionally so that the volume of the reaction mix

was 10µl. Electrophoresis and genotyping were

performed in a AbI310 Genetic Analyzer (Ap-

plied biosystems) using the GeneScan v.3.7 and

Genotyper v3.7 software. All loci included in the

AmpFlSTR Identifiler and PowerPlex Y System

were amplified and compared with profiles of

putative parents (table I).

CASE REPORT

In April 2006, an unrecognized male corpse

was transferred to the Department of Forensic

Medicine, Medical University of białystok. The

investigation data revealed that the victim was

shot dead and his body was concealed in

a ground ditch filled with slaked lime (calcium

hydroxide, Ca(OH)2). Removal of the thick

lime deposits from the cadaver surface prior

to autopsy disclosed signs of putrefaction and

adipocere formation (fig. 1). For identification

purposes, two tattoo patterns revealed on the

upper extremities were photographed. based

on the skeletal and dental findings, the victim’s

age was estimated at 30-35 years. During the

autopsy, two gunshot wounds to the head and

the chest were found. The track of the former

wound led through the brain disclosing a pre-

sumptive cause of death. The character of the

injuries, gunshot wound tracks and investigation

findings were confirmatory of a homicide case.

For genetic identification purposes, samples

of brain, lung, kidney, spleen and femur were

collected (fig. 2). DNA was extracted using

a modified organic procedure: the specimens

were placed in 1.5 ml Eppendorf tubes and

incubated overnight at 56°C in 0.5 ml digestive

buffer pH 7.5 (10mM Tris-HCl, 10mM EDTA, 50

mM NaCl, 2% SDS) with 0.3 mg/ml proteinase

K (Sigma); the centrifuged pellets (Eppendorf,

16500 rpm, 1 min) were discarded and the as-

pirated supernatants were transferred to fresh

tubes containing 0.5 ml phenol-chloroform-iso-

amyl alcohol mix (Sigma); after centrifugation at

16500 rpm for 5 min (Eppendorf), the resultant

supernatants were transferred to fresh tubes;

the latter step was repeated 2-3 times until the

phenol phase became transparent; DNA prepa-

rations were concentrated and purified using

the QIAquick PCR Purification Kit (Qiagen). The

recovered DNA was quantitated fluorometrically

[10, 11]. DNA quality was assessed by ethid-

ium bromide 2% agarose gel electrophoresis.

Polymorphic autosomal systems: D8S1179,

Fig. 1. Gross appearance of the cadaver.

Ryc. 1. Ogólny wygląd zwłok.

Fig. 2. Gross appearance of the brain.

Ryc. 2. Ogólny wygląd mózgu.

250 Nr 3

Anna Niemcunowicz-Janica

Table I. Genetic identification results.

Tabela I. Wyniki identyfikacji genetycznej.

Autosomal profiles

Profile autosomalne

Y-chromosome profiles

Profile chromosomu Y

Locus

N/n corpse

N/n zwłoki

Putative mother

Domniemana

matka

Putative father

Domniemany

ojciec

Locus

N/n corpse

N/n zwłoki

Putative father

Domniemany ojciec

D8S1179 11,12 12,13

11,13

DYS391 11 11

D21S11 29,32.2 28,32.2 28,29

DYS389I 14 14

D7S820 11,12 12

11,12

DYS439 12 12

CSF1PO 11 11

DYS389II 30 30

D3S1358 15,16 15,17

16,17

DYS438 12 12

TH01 6

6,9.3

DYS437 14 14

D13S317 11,12 11,12

8,11

DYS19 14 14

D16S539 11,12 12

11,12

DYS392 13 13

D2S1338 17,24 17,24

19,24

DYS393 13 13

D19S433 13,15.2 15,15.2 13,15

DYS390 24 24

vWA 17 16,17

16,17

DYS385 11,14 11,14

TPOX 8,11 10,11 8,11

D18S51 18 15,18 12,18

D5S818 11,12 11 11,12

FGA 22.2,23 22.2,23 23

AMG XY X XY

MI = 578955,67 PI = 40625,31

PI = 1250

MI – maternity index (indeks macierzyństwa), PI – paternity index (indeks ojcostwa)

DISCUSSION

the present case. The cadaver under study was

concealed immediately after death and exposed

postmortem to the slaked lime environment for

four years, what resulted in adipocere formation.

The process involves conversion of body fat into

solid white substances and is characterized by

hydrolysis and hydrogenation of fatty tissue into

a mixture of predominantly saturated fatty acids

(myristic, palmitic, stearic). Unsaturated fatty ac-

ids (oleic and palmitoleic), calcium salts of fatty

acids, hydroxyl and oxo-fatty acids have all been

identified as constituents of adipocere. Their pres-

ence is of a special interest to forensic scientists

as they have a potential to inhibit decomposi-

tion and thus to preserve the tissue material in

a varying degree depending on the surrounding

environment [8]. The optimum environment for

adipocere formation described by many authors

may be damp, warm, anaerobic conditions [17,

18, 19, 20]. We suggest that such factors acted on

the corpse under study and resulted in preserva-

tion of DNA sufficient for successful genotyping of

all loci of the AmpFlSTR Identifiler and PowerPlex

Y System.

Genetic profiling is a potential method of choice

in contemporary personal identification of unrec-

ognized human corpses and remains [1, 3, 4, 5,

12]. In the presented case, the DNA source was

represented by soft tissue samples. DNA was

extracted using the organic method, commonly

employed in genetic identification of mass disaster

victims [13, 14]. The method was also reported

as the most efficient in DNA extraction from aged

blood specimens [15]. The usefulness of soft

tissues in genetic typing was described by other

authors [6, 7, 12], who successfully typed DNA

profiles in cadavers within postmortem interval of

2 to 132 days. Extracted DNA yield ranged from

3 to 6 ng. The AmpFlSTR Identifiler kit was vali-

dated as highly specific and sensitive for human

DNA and suitable in typing of degraded samples

[16]. The authors of the present paper previously

reported typeability of AmpFlSTR SGM Plus loci

in specimens of human organs stored in selected

soil environments [9]; however, the success rates

were significantly lower than those observed in

Nr 3 251

IDENTYFIKACJA GENETYCZNA OFIARY POSTRZAłU

REFERENCES

11. brunk C. F., Jones K. C., James T. W.: As-

say for nanogram quantities of DNA in cellular

homogenates. Anal bioch. 1979, 92, 497-500.

12. Graw M., Weisser H. J., Lutz S.: DNA typ-

ing of human remains found in damp environ-

ments. Forensic Sci Int. 2000, 113, 91-95.

13. Clayton T. M., Whitaker J. P., Maquire C. N.:

Identification of bodies from scene of a mass disas-

ter using DNA amplification of short tandem repeat

(STR) loci. Forensic Sci Int. 1995, 76, 7-15.

14. Olaisen b., Stenersen M., Mevåg b.: Iden-

tification by DNA analyses of the victims of the

august 1996 Spitsbergen civil aircraft disaster.

Nat Genet. 1997, 15, 670-677.

15. Maciejewska A., Pawłowski R.: Influence

of DNA degradation on amplification Profiler Plus

loci. Arch Med Sąd i Krym 2001, 3, 217-226.

16. Collins P. J., Hennessy L. K., Leibelt C. S.,

Roby R. K., Reeder D. J., Foxall P. A.: Developmen-

tal validation of a single-tube amplification of the 13

CODIS STR loci, D2S1338, D19S433, and amelo-

genin: the AmpFlSTR Identifiler PCR Amplification

Kit. J Forensic Sci. 2004, 49, 1265-1277.

17. bereuter T. L., Mikenda W., Reiter C.: Ice-

man’s mummification - implications from infrared

spectroscopical and histological studies. Chem

Eur J. 1997, 3, 1032-1038.

18. Forbes S. L., Dent D. b., Stuart b. H.:

The effect of soil type on adipocere formation.

Forensic Sci Int. 2005, 154, 35-43.

19. Forbes S. L., Stuart b. H., Dent b. b.: The

effect of the burial environment on adipocere

formation. Forensic Sci Int. 2005, 154, 24-34.

20. boddington A., Garland A. N., Janaway

C. (eds).: Death, Decay and Reconstruction: Ap-

proaches to Archeology and Forensic Science.

University Press, Manchester, 1987. Chapter:

Knowledge Acquired From Post-War-Exhuma-

tions. Mant AK; p. 65-78.

1. bilge J., Kedici P. S., Alakoç Y. D., Ülküer K.

U., İlkyaz Y. Y.: The identification of dismembered

human body: a multidisciplinary approach. Fo-

rensic Sci Int. 2003, 137, 141-146.

2. Evison M. P., Smillie D. M., Chamberlain A.

T.: Extraction of single-copy nuclear DNA from

forensic specimens with a variety of postmortem

histories. J Forensic Sci. 1997, 42, 1032-1038.

3. Mukaida M., Kimura H., Takada Y., Masuda

T., Nakata Y.: The personal identification of many

samples recovered from under the sea. Forensic

Sci Int. 2000, 113, 79-85.

4. Smith b. C., Fisher D. L., Weedn V. W.,

Warnock G. R., Holland M. M.: A systematic

approach to the sampling of dental DNA. J Fo-

rensic Sci. 1993, 38, 1194-1209.

5. Staiti N., Di Marino D., Saravo L.: A novel

approach in personal identification from tissue

samples undergone different process through

STR typing. Forensic Sci Int. 2004, 146 S, 171-

173.

6. Hoff-Olsen P., Jacobsen S., Mevåg b.,

Olaisen b.: Microsatellite stability in human

post-mortem tissues. Forensic Sci Int. 2001,

119, 273-278.

7. Hoff-Olsen P., Mevåg b., Staalstrøm E.,

Hovde b., Egeland T., Olaisen b.: Extraction

of DNA from decomposed human tissue. An

evaluation of five extraction methods for short

tandem repeat typing. Forensic Sci Int. 1999,

105, 171-183.

8. Hunter J., Roberts C., Martin A. (eds):

Studies in Crime: An Introduction to Forensic

Archeology. Routledge, London, 1997. Chapter:

The Decay Of buried Human Remains And Their

Associated Materials. Janaway RC; p. 58-85.

9. Niemcunowicz-Janica A., Pepinski W.,

Janica J. R., Skawronska M., Janica J., Koc-

Zorawska E., Soltyszewski I.: Detectability of

SGM Plus profiles in selected tissue samples

incubated in soil environment. Int Congress

Series. 2006, 1288, 529-531.

10. bontemps I., Houssier C., Frederig E.:

Physico-chemical study of the complex of

“33258 Hoechst” with DNA and nucleohistone.

Nucleic Acids Res. 1975, 2, 971-984.

Corresponding author:

dr hab. n. med. Witold Pepinski

Department of Forensic Medicine

Medical Univeristy of białystok

ul. Waszyngtona 13, 15-269 białystok, Poland

e-mail: pepinski@umwb.edu.pl

Plik z chomika:

Inne pliki z tego folderu:

Inne foldery tego chomika: